Aeropostale files for Ch. 11 and wants to investigate its lender
May 4, 2016 09:30 AM
(Bloomberg)—Aeropostale Inc., the teen clothing chain, filed for bankruptcy and asked a court for permission to investigate Sycamore Partners, saying its main lender forced it to deteriorate via a supplier it also controlled.
Aeropsotale is No. 154 in the Internet Retailer 2016 Top 500 Guide, with estimated 2015 web sales of $219 million, according to Top500Guide.com data.
The Chapter 11 petition filed Wednesday in New York follows meltdowns by American Apparel Inc. (No. 338), Quiksilver Inc. (No. 703 in the 2015 Second 500) and Sports Authority Inc. (No. 287). Mall-based retailers have struggled to adapt to online sales and the changing tastes of teenagers. New York-based Aeropostale has also had to contend with fast-fashion competitors that get new trends on shelves sooner.
Online competition isn’t the only source of the company’s woes, CEO Julian Geiger said in court papers blaming decisions of Sycamore Partners, which also owns a key clothing supplier, MGF Sourcing.
In a 2013 conversation about naming Geiger to Aeropostale’s board, Sycamore’s managing director Stefan Kaluzny told him to “do nothing” and “just observe” because “his plan was to let Aeropostale deteriorate so that he could buy the company in bankruptcy,” Geiger said in court papers.
When Geiger complained last year that MGF’s prices were too high, causing Aeropostale to pay $25 million more than it would for comparable merchandise from competing suppliers, Kaluzny said he had to make his numbers at MGF, Geiger said in the complaint.
Sycamore denied the allegations.
“Any such action would be counter-productive to its large financial investment in the company,” according to Michael Freitag, a spokesman for Sycamore, who noted that it was formerly Aeropostale’s largest shareholder and is the retailer’s largest secured creditor. MGF’s sourcing agreement with Aeropostale requires MGF to provide product at competitive prices, and the chain is free to source product from competing vendors, he said.
Aeropostale, a brand established by R.H. Macy & Co. in the early 1980s, expanded and became part of Federated Department Stores Inc. before going public in 2002. Sycamore stepped in during the summer and fall of 2013 when its affiliate Lemur LLC bought 8 percent of Aeropostale’s equity in the open market, the company said in court papers. Sycamore and entities it controls have developed relationships with Aeropostale since 2014, and Sycamore also owns Aero Investors LLC, its largest secured creditor, according to court papers.
It plans to close 154 stores immediately, according to papers filed in the bankruptcy. As of the 2015 fiscal year end, it operated 811 stores, and it currently has 14,500 employees, court records state. Since 2013, Aeropostale has closed about 215 stores, Poonam Goyal, a senior retail analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence, said in a report in April.
Kaluzny and Sycamore Partners didn’t immediately return calls for comment before usual business hours Wednesday. Aeropostale has asked the court to appoint an independent examiner to probe Sycamore and Kaluzny, along with others.
In response to earlier allegations that Sycamore had violated a sourcing agreement with Aeropostale, the private equity firm denied the allegation, saying, “In fact, MGF has taken action to protect itself by reducing payment terms as permitted under the agreement.”
A smaller Aeropostale would emerge from the Chapter 11 process within the next six months, the company said.
The company said it secured a commitment for $160 million in debtor-in-possession financing from Crystal Financial LLC, which, combined with operating cash flow, will allow the retailer to meet financial commitments.
Bankruptcy can make shuttering stores easier because of rules that allow companies to cancel contracts, including leases. But the U.S. Bankruptcy Code also grants landlords rights they can exercise to pressure a retailer into reorganizing quickly or liquidating.
Aeropostale’s filing follows three straight years of losses. It had also feuded with Sycamore prior to its bankruptcy, saying in March that MGF was holding up the delivery of merchandise and violating the terms of its agreement. The retailer said on April 15 that it would delay filing its annual report because it was distracted by the fight with MGF.
In March, Aeropostale tapped Stifel Financial Corp. to help assess a possible sale or restructuring. The company also is working with law firm Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP and FTI Consulting Inc. on the filing.
Suppliers to the U.S. retailer include Hampshire Group Ltd., a New York-based maker of sweaters, and Hong Kong’s Li & Fung Ltd., which also supplies clothing and toys for major retailers such as Wal-Mart Stores Inc., according to supply chain data compiled by Bloomberg. A spokeswoman for Li & Fung said the company declined to comment.
Aeropostale listed $390 million in total debt and about $354 million of assets in its Chapter 11 petition.
The case is In re Aeropostale Inc., 16-11275, U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan).